People need to stop thinking that excess protein intake when sedentary will develop muscle. The bottom line is that excess calories consumed beyond total daily energy expenditure will cause weight gain. And not the muscular kind of weight. Protein has 4 calories per gram so it’s not a freebie diet food that magically builds muscle. It only builds muscle if you exercise. Not sitting on yer arse.
Yeah the current marketing obsession with protein just screams fad diet. Remember “super foods” where you try to throw certain nutrient dense ingredients into all of your food? Whatever happened to that?
True, I did notice that & apologize for not acknowledging that part. But they also said “excess” protein consumption. Excess protein intake will cause fat gain because that’s what excess calories from any source will do. Another commenter said that excess protein will be pooped out as long as the person is getting enough calories & nutrients from other sources, so that’s something I’ve never heard before, but the bottom line is that excess calories equals fat gain.
Depends on how you are defining excess. Excess of 2000 calories yes. Excess of the daily reccomended amount of protein no not necessarily. It just depends on how the rest of their diet is portioned. You can eat 200g of protien a day and not exceed daily calorie allotments.
A cousin of mine who games all day started chugging protein for 3 years from 15-18. Dude became really bulky, like big, but not really muscular. Sometimes I genuinely can’t tell if he’s fat or 50.
I think a more correct term would be mass-growth, not muscle growth.
Protein is only used as fuel in extremis, it’s a dirty fuel and the body will poop what it doesn’t need for repair if there’s enough other calories coming in. Also only some amino acids are biochemically amenable to conversion to energy, whereas the 4cal/g figure is from burning it all in air. Protein does not turn into cake, you can however argue the excess is wasted, but how much is excess for a given individual is a hard question.
You’re quite right about needing stimulus to grow, but the statement was about maintenance.
That reminds me of one lady a few years ago who came to realize that her protein shakes were actually literally cake batter repackaged & labeled as a lie. Big scandal she uncovered and she outed that company until they stopped their crimes.
The didn’t say that. They say it encourages retention as opposed to muscle loss. It’s true. Get off your weird soapbox, your fact while true wasn’t relevant here.
Flex yer glutes while sitting. Pump em up, do 20 sets of 20 repetitions, and get some amusement out of people’s reactions as they walk by seeing you riding your invisible horse on your chair.
I made a protein comment like this earlier too and people thought I was making a joke buy protein powder is mostly wheat protein and men can get weird and meat has lots of fat and men can get real weird and I’ve gwd some strange cakes requested by straight friends back when I had those
People need to stop thinking that excess protein intake when sedentary will develop muscle. The bottom line is that excess calories consumed beyond total daily energy expenditure will cause weight gain. And not the muscular kind of weight. Protein has 4 calories per gram so it’s not a freebie diet food that magically builds muscle. It only builds muscle if you exercise. Not sitting on yer arse.
Plus excess protein is bad for you. Your body just has to work harder to filter anything you don’t use out.
Yeah the current marketing obsession with protein just screams fad diet. Remember “super foods” where you try to throw certain nutrient dense ingredients into all of your food? Whatever happened to that?
The SuperFood fad is timeless wisdom. People who stick with that are golden.
Almonds, blueberries, quinoa, avocado, bone broth, walnuts, salmon, kale, spinach etc 💕
They didn’t say it would cause muscle gain, they said prevents muscle loss. Those are two very different claims
True, I did notice that & apologize for not acknowledging that part. But they also said “excess” protein consumption. Excess protein intake will cause fat gain because that’s what excess calories from any source will do. Another commenter said that excess protein will be pooped out as long as the person is getting enough calories & nutrients from other sources, so that’s something I’ve never heard before, but the bottom line is that excess calories equals fat gain.
Depends on how you are defining excess. Excess of 2000 calories yes. Excess of the daily reccomended amount of protein no not necessarily. It just depends on how the rest of their diet is portioned. You can eat 200g of protien a day and not exceed daily calorie allotments.
Really depends on their definition of excess
A cousin of mine who games all day started chugging protein for 3 years from 15-18. Dude became really bulky, like big, but not really muscular. Sometimes I genuinely can’t tell if he’s fat or 50.
I think a more correct term would be mass-growth, not muscle growth.
He’s fat he just has it evenly distributed. Evenly distributed fat is genetic not what he’s eating
He’s cultivating mass.
deleted by creator
Protein is only used as fuel in extremis, it’s a dirty fuel and the body will poop what it doesn’t need for repair if there’s enough other calories coming in. Also only some amino acids are biochemically amenable to conversion to energy, whereas the 4cal/g figure is from burning it all in air. Protein does not turn into cake, you can however argue the excess is wasted, but how much is excess for a given individual is a hard question.
You’re quite right about needing stimulus to grow, but the statement was about maintenance.
You can turn protein into cake I’ve done it
Haha yes fat ass joke
But on a serious note
That reminds me of one lady a few years ago who came to realize that her protein shakes were actually literally cake batter repackaged & labeled as a lie. Big scandal she uncovered and she outed that company until they stopped their crimes.
Not crimes to do that here but wasteful why not use cat litter
I do it about twice a week as I don’t eat enough fiber.
Fair cop.
The didn’t say that. They say it encourages retention as opposed to muscle loss. It’s true. Get off your weird soapbox, your fact while true wasn’t relevant here.
I got four hours of exercise today sitting on my arse
Flex yer glutes while sitting. Pump em up, do 20 sets of 20 repetitions, and get some amusement out of people’s reactions as they walk by seeing you riding your invisible horse on your chair.
Or ride a bicycle.
Oh! You weren’t being facetious 😄 you really DO get 4 hours of exercise sitting on your arse.
I have an “Elliptigo SUB (stand-up bike)” It’s got no seat. I love it so much.
I made a protein comment like this earlier too and people thought I was making a joke buy protein powder is mostly wheat protein and men can get weird and meat has lots of fat and men can get real weird and I’ve gwd some strange cakes requested by straight friends back when I had those
Perhaps, but nobody in this thread argued it built muscle, only helps retain it if you’re sedentary.