

You’re overlooking one aspect. Legislatures around the world have embraced forcing these big companies into opening affiliate offices in their countries or be blocked from access without VPNs. This legislation often specifically includes the threat of holding the appointed local representative legally liable. I think that’s the case in Brazil and they may have imprisoned a Twitter or Facebook guy before, briefly. A beautiful social media company you have there. It’s be a shame if anything happened to it.
The local office often also has financial benefits for the big company, as they can handle payments in local currency and thus forgo having to do all transactions in USD, which with exchange rates may lower the bang for your buck for ad partners and the social media giant alike. So pulling out of a country has real financial consequences.
A lot of these fines don’t have teeth for billion dollar companies. That’s why newer legislation makes fines not a fiver per violation but a percentage of worldwide revenue. And that can hurt. And millions of dollars in fines down under, in Italy, in the US, in wherever - it piles up and ends up hurting them. Making it less likely they close up shop in, say, Australia and pull out of that market altogether. It’s possible, of course, but up until now not very likely.
4chan was an example where they didn’t gaf. But they’re not as big as Meta, nor do they deal in the same league financially. Google pulled out of China so they wouldn’t have to comply with Chinese law. If you consider YouTube a social medium, then they’re an example of a company like that pulling out of a substantial market. But examples like that are rare. The money interests up until now override the fear of fines.
And the fines you read in the headlines often also have a tendency to decrease a lot in follow up legislation that isn’t sexy enough for headlines anymore.







One way around that is to limit purchases to reasonable quantities per household. So you can’t buy a full gross of $.25 mountain dew knock-off to sell outside in the first place. Makes it harder to start a side hustle. Not impossible but the required effort will be more of a hurdle.
I don’t think we should look at this local supermarket idea as one that needs to work 100% from the very start. They may make mistakes and they can fix them. One fix might be an ID check through the backdoor by using a local payment service that only residents have access to. When have politicians not changed their mind about something they said before. The payment service could just not collect and sell data.
The reason why I am quite forgiving is that I fear we are looking at a future where supermarket shopping will be automated to max out prices individually for every customer like the airlines have practiced with us for more than a decade. The cheap TV dinner you put in your cart has just gone up $2 before you had a chance to check out. Digital price tags can let them change prices like gas stations. In a pessimistic future you will scan and pay for every item the moment you lift it off the shelf at an algorithmically maxed out price. After all, we carry an identifier device with us wherever we go. Capitalists rejoice! Introducing an operation with reliably lower prices may be a good first step to correct for more troubling trends and dystopic threats.
If these Mamdaniesque ideas could be combined with wage growth in the lower rungs in the supply chains and a reduction of bonuses in their boardrooms, you’d have a more holistic approach to the redistribution of wealth many societies around the world badly need.