I have been using Gnome, which I love, but realized my 13 year old laptop may benefit from a lighter DE. XFCE seems potentially cool but it looks quite bad out the box and I miss the keyboard functions of Gnome… :( any cool looking recs? Or how to make Gnome lighter?
I don’t need a full de. I just use x11 and jwm with whatever apps I need at a given moment.
I use Xfce on high end systems. Low end is for tty+tmux.
I’d suggest antiX linux https://antixlinux.com/ Based off the Debian stable branch. Runs perfect on low spec hardware, and the full edition is loaded with tons of useful stuff :-)
At this point, anything but GNOME should be fine. KDE can be surprisingly light anymore. Lxqt if you are feeling extreme
I had to drop KDE due to unsolvable akonadi problems. So many solutions require deleting things like Knotes etc. to stop it popping up.
I always end up returning to TDE, which works fine on some quite ancient systems. Might not be to your taste if you’re used to Gnome, though.
I use
niri+noctaliaon Macbook Air 2013 andriver+waybaron Thinkpad X201 from 2010.Depending on your specs, any DE could be heavy for you. You probably would have a better chance with WMs. However WM usually means manual configuration. So, depending on your situation too.
KDE.
It uses as much ram as XFCE nowadays. It’s a bit heavier on the CPU side though, although you can have it be lighter by disabling animations, transparency, or other fancy things.
If you want something even lighter than both, enlightenment looks nice and has good functionality while being extremely lightweight.
+1
I already DE shopped for a PC to minimize RAM/VRAM usage, and couldn’t beat stripped KDE.
Disable fancy effects, disable services you don’t need (by looking at their RAM usage), and it’s shockingly light.
Same experience here. The days of KDE being the heavier DE are no more. I was shocked when I booted CachyOS for the first time without tinkering at all.
CachyOS
They riced it a little though
To be fair I am using CachyOS too, so I got their baseline config.
There are still a few heavy services to cut, but it’s pretty good OOTB.
disable services you don’t need
Baloo 🤬
Yeah, Baloo is a menace. The secrets manager can be, too, though it’s behaving for me now.
I switched to using KDE on my old Thinkpad recently and it’s been great. Modern KDE strikes the right balance between efficiency and features for me.
I had previously been using XFCE, MATE or simpler lightweight WMs on that system but I can’t see myself going back now.
I highly doubt that KDE runs on 550 MB of RAM, as XFce does on my Arch.
What do you mean by lightweight? I’ve been running Gnome on a 4 GB ram machine, was pretty useful, unless you open many browser tabs.
These days I use Sway, and I quite like it. But you need to invest resources into learning it, and then training it, so to acquire some muscle memory. After that, very cool, I like it. And it is very minimalistic.
I run Sway on both my Linux tablets (Lenovo Miix 2 with 2 GB ram and Surface 3 with 4 GB ram), and I’m pretty happy about it. But I understand the limitations. Say, a 2 GB ram tablet is not good for browsing, so I ditched Firefox for Epiphany and run it only when I really need it. (Mostly never.) Some basic files work, not much different from my loaded laptop. On a 4 GB ram device, it’s better, and I run my browser more often there, but not that often still.
Once you understand the limitations, I think you can successfully run any DE. I think Linux has no ‘bloated DE’ problem. All of them are mostly good, including the two major ones, Gnome and KDE.
IME gnome feels sluggish on old laptops, even after disabling animation effects. i have 8gb on it for reference.
Gnome runs fine on my 2014 MacBook pro w/8GB.
LXQt but for one much older laptop, I use none, just JWM, a window manager.
no love for MATE? the only reason i gave up on it was the wonderful theming clashed too much with the look of apps that didn’t respect the application theme
Lean into Xfce’s retro aesthetic with the Chicago95 theme? I’ve been using it and really enjoy it.
And what keyboard functions are you referring to? Xfce has customizable keyboard shortcuts and some preconfigured.
That one is nice, thank you.
I like that the super key allows me to search for the app I want to open. Also all apps on the task bar can be opened with SK plus number. Those are basic ones I use often.
Take a look at the Whisker menu for xfce, it gives you that ability from gnome to press super, type your app and hit enter to run it at least.
To set the Super key to open the Whisker menu in XFCE, go to Settings > Keyboard > Application Shortcuts, add a new shortcut with the command xfce4-popup-whiskermenu, and assign it to the Super key.
Sway. Ditch the DE and get with a keyboard controlled window manager. You can always install whatever specific DE apps you absolutely need.
I still use GNOME on my desktop, but I will always use a keyboard-controlled window manager on my laptops.
+1 for Sway. It runs great on my converted Chromebook with 2GB of RAM and 2 cores
Another one I thought of. If keyboard driven is your jam Enlightenment is pretty barebones, very lightweight and can be almost completely keyboard driven IIRC. It has been a while since I have used it but I remember when I was on it I could get away with very little mouse usage.
XFCE is on X11 and the ecosystem is shrinking, long term you may have to migrate again. On the plus side they started work on a wayland compositor:










